Jan 04

The Debate: High Bicarbonate in Irrigation Water

High salinity, high sodium, and potential ion toxicity from irrigation water are problems that are all commonly agreed upon by turfgrass managers and turfgrass researchers alike. However, the issue of whether medium to high bicarbonate levels in irrigation water (see Table 1 below) are a concern if sodium levels in the irrigation water are low, or in non-akaline soils, is much less clear.


Turfgrass problems - Salinity Sodium Ion Toxicity


There are anecdotal reports that high bicarbonate levels in irrigation water may reduce soil infiltration rates in non-arid regions during extended dry or true-drought conditions.

The hypothesis for this idea argues that bicarbonate anions (HCO3-) and calcium cations (Ca2+) precipitate out as calcium carbonate (CaCO3) when the soil dries and these tiny calcium carbonate mineral deposits can partially plug pore spaces in the soil resulting in reduced permeability. On the other hand, chemical equilibrium simulation software predicts bicarbonate anions and calcium cations only precipitate out as calcium carbonate in alkaline soils.

Ongoing research investigating these questions will hopefully settle this debate. Until then, testing for this calcium carbonate layer formation using an excess carbonate/free lime “fizz” test may be a useful tool to identify whether a calcium carbonate layer, significant enough to reduce infiltration rates, has actually formed in soils irrigated with irrigation water containing high bicarbonate levels.

Conducting an Excess Carbonate “Fizz Test”

Calcite formation in the soil can cause problems with infiltration and permeability. A common test to determine whether a soil contains calcium carbonate is a “Fizz” test.

During this test, a dilute hydrochloric acid solution is poured onto a soil sample. If it “fizzes” and a gas is given off, calcium carbonate is present. This test can be used to determine if the entire soil is calcareous or if there is a layer of calcium carbonate at a certain depth in a non-calcareous soil, when a soil core is tested.

Want to learn more about potential issues with your water quality? Download our FREE Guide to Assessing and Managing Turfgrass Salinity Issues in Irrigation Water and Soils.


About The Author

More than 60 years ago, Aquatrols introduced the world’s first commercially available soil wetting agent. Since creating an entirely new product category to address water management challenges and opportunities, the company has remained a top innovator and producer of high-performance soil surfactants and related technologies. Aquatrols’ advanced product suite optimizes soil-water-plant interactions in agricultural, professional turfgrass, and horticultural industries in more than 40 countries. Headquartered in southern New Jersey, Aquatrols also has offices in the United Kingdom and conducts business on six continents.